It was in Becky Mandelbaum's class where I wrote the short story that got me into a Tin House summer workshop, and which served as the seed story for the novel I'm working on. In subsequent classes, I got to know Becky as a fiercely intelligent, heart-smart teacher with a deep knowledge of craft and unerring, intuitive sense of story. Her careful attention to my work helped me understand the nuances of dialogue and inspired me to aim for an elegant economy with my words. Becky responds to her students from a deep place of empathy and reverence for the tales they bring to the page, yet always with a discerning eye for how to deliver the most rewarding experience for the reader. In one of my submissions, her astute grasp of narrative structure—suggesting that I move an element in my story further toward the ending, for maximum impact—made the story infinitely better. And here's the thing. Although I've taken a slew of writing classes, rarely have I fallen head over heels in love with the writing of a particular instructor. This happened with Becky. When I read her short stories, I knew I was in the hands of a truly gifted writer and master storyteller. If you’re looking for an exceptionally generous manuscript coach—one who will create a sacred space for your work to be the best it can be on its own terms—I highly recommend Becky Mandelbaum.
—Reni Roxas, children's book publisher and editor
In whatever form I submit my writing, Becky always, with delicate precision, offers sage advice in adapting what’s on the page toward something spectacular. She gently directs me toward what is working and, along the way, makes it easier to let go of the attachment to my “darlings”. Her expertise in editing, story structure, and flow has streamlined my process so that my initial submissions need less and less refinement. Her writing and teaching prowess is unparalleled and deeply valued. However painful, shameful, and challenging the content, Becky guides me into ascertaining the “aboutness” of the story, making her just as much a writing coach as a she is a mentor and friend.
—Kevin Sikes
Working with Becky Mandelbaum was the best decision I’ve made for my novel. I hired her to do a developmental edit, and it was the first time anyone had read the manuscript all the way through. Becky asked a lot of questions before she began, and it was clear she wanted to understand what was important to me. That really came through in her feedback. She approached my novel with care and really took it on its own terms. This was clear in her feedback, which was extensive and thorough. Her comments showed that she tried to appreciate the characters and intention of the novel. She gave me exactly the insights I needed to be able to move forward with edits. There was not a single comment that seemed off base to me. Then she took the time to have a phone conversation where she answered all of my questions. I’ve received a lot of feedback on writing over the course of my career, and I can say without exaggeration that Becky is the best reader I’ve had. I can’t express enough how grateful I am that I was able to work with her.
—Vanessa Freije
Becky provided excellent developmental editing on my book draft. She was able to see the story I wanted to tell and had innovative suggestions. I needed help enriching my main character and she gave me concrete ideas for how to do that – and it worked! She was timely and professional. It was a pleasure to work with her.
—Jena Martin
Becky’s feedback was thorough and easy to follow. I especially appreciated her help with my novel’s query letter, whose message she pulled through and made sound marketable. The whole process of querying agents feels more attainable now. – Anna Davis-Abel
When I found Becky, I'd been working on my short story for so long that I'd lost its thread and was on the verge of scrapping it. At the time, contacting her felt like a Hail Mary, but in retrospect, it was a shrewd move. During our initial consultation she asked good questions and listened carefully to my answers; but it was after she read the story and delivered her feedback that her diagnostic brilliance became clear. She was able to see through the confusion to the heart of the story, and her "yes, and…" way of delivering feedback led me unerringly to the places that could be improved, and at the same time encouraged me. Her enthusiasm for my story rekindled my own, and because of her insight, instead of scrapping it, I was able to engage with it more deeply. I’ll continue to ask her to assess the health and fitness of my writing projects as long as she’ll let me! – Lisa Holt